The Rocky Collection
Reviewed by Edwin Samuelson on May 20, 2001
|

|
 |
In 1976 Sylvester Stallone wrote a
script for a boxing film called Rocky after he saw a fight in which
Mohammed Ali was given a surprise when he fought an unknown fighter
named Chuck Wepner. Everyone expected to be an easy for fight for
Ali, but that wasn't the case. Ali was knocked down in a fight that
lasted 15 rounds. Stallone sold the rights to make the
film with the condition that he be cast in the title role. Producers
offered him a lot of money if he would let someone else play the
role, be he refused. The studio finally agreed to let him star in
the film if could be done for a million dollars. John G. Avilsen was hired to
direct and with Stallone brought us a film that went onto become a huge smash
and hit a chord with critics and audiences alike. Rocky later went onto win Oscars for best picture
and director.
|
| After Rocky Stallone became a hot property and used his leverage to write,
direct, star and even sing main song to Paradise Alley. The film didn't do too
well, nor did his next film, F.I.S.T. So Stallone made another Rocky film - most
people thought to themselves, why? Stallone this time took the director's
chair and did the unthinkable; he made a film that was just as good as the
original and added more to the character, instead of rehashing him. |
 |
 |
Three more sequels of varying quality followed. After
watching all the films back to back, one thing that is quite interesting to see
is how Rocky's simple minded persona changed into a GQ cover man in the later
sequels! Seeing Rocky fight Mr. T, a mad Russian and professional boxer Tommy Morrison
were mindless fun and offered entertainment, but no real substance. |
|
|
VIDEO---All films presented in this set are presented widescreen
(1.85.1). The original Rocky, Rocky III and Rocky IV are anamorphic, while Rocky
II and IV are recycled non-anamorphic transfers from their previous DVD
releases in 97.
Rocky looks very good, but it's somewhat disappointing as the print has some
wear in the form of specs that pop up from time to time and grain. Color is very
strong, but black level is more of a light gray than black.
Rocky II is also a bit of a letdown as the there is a quite a bit of dirt on
the print and grain is thick. Colors are good, but nowhere as good as Rocky. A
full frame version is also included on the flipside of the disc.
Rocky III - Colors are very strong and like the other Rocky films this one
has a lot of grain. However, the print is in good shape and it's anamorphic,
which adds a lot of detail.
Rocky IV - The print used here is in good shape as colors are good, but
unfortunately has some edge enhancement as well as some digital artifacts.
Like Rocky II, a full frame version is included on the flipside of
the disc.
Rocky V - Of all of the discs in this set, Rocky V is the best as it was the most
recent. It has a crisp look and nice color reproduction. All the previous DVDs
had a problem with grain - while this movie has some slight grain it's not as
bad.
|
AUDIO---Rocky is has a new Dolby Digital 5.1 as well as the original
mono track. The 5.1 sounds very good, but it's really a mono track that
sometimes contains a little kick. The music and dialogue sound clear.
Rocky II has a mono track, which delivers clean dialogue, but offers no real
power.
Rocky III has a new 5.1 track, which has some nice bass action with clean dialogue,
but you'll need to keep your remote handy as the the sound is uneven in terms of
volume.
Rocky IV has a 5.1 track as well. Dialog comes though nice and clean
with great use of surrounds.
Rocky V has a Dolby Digital Surround track. Rocky V has the best video
quality and also the best audio quality as it's the most recent film. It has
clean dialogue with nice use of surround and bass action.
|
|
EXTRAS--- The discs with the except of the original Rocky are almost
complete devoid of extras. All discs have trailers, but that's about it. Rocky
has has a new audio commentary with John G. Avildsen, Talia Shire, Carl Weathers Burt Young, cameraman Garrett Brown and producers Robert Chartoff and Irwin
Winkler. All were recorded separately and edited into a coherent track with no
lapses. The result is a very informative track. Next up is a video commentary with Stallone in which he talks of his love for
the Rocky character and how by a near miracle Rocky came together during a
chance encounter.
Next is a some silent 8 mm test footage of Stallone and Carl Weathers rehearing
for the final showdown. Director John G. Avildsen introduces the footage and talks how
filming them practice saved a lot of time and money.
Finally there are a pair of nice tributes to Burgess Meredith and Rocky's cinematographer,
James Crabe. Stallone, Burt Young, Carl Weathers and Lee Grant talk about his
craft and remember him. The Tribute to James Crabe, runs around three
minutes and it's mostly Avilsen talking about his good friend who help make the
film a success.
|
OVERALL--- The Rocky Collection is a mixed bag. I feel
that MGM should given more care to the sequels in the video and
extras, instead of repacking old masters. I do recommend the
first disc as it has a new anamorphic transfer with a nice amount of
extras, but the rest of the set is disappointing.
|
Year:
1976, 1979, 1982, 1985, 1990
DVD
by: MGM
Rated:
PG and PG-13
Retail
price: $89.95
Aspect
Ratio: 1.85:1
Sound:
-
English 5.1 Surround
- English 2.0 Surround
- English 2.0 Mono
- French 5.1 Surround
- French 2.0 Mono
- Spanish 2.0 Mono
|
Directors:
Sylvester Stallone
John
G. Avildsen
Cast:
Sylvester Stallone
Talia
Shire
Burt
Young
Burgess
Meredith
Carl
Weathers
|
OVERALL
3/5
Disagree with this review
or want to share your feelings?
Then post in the Forum
under feedback.
|