Jin Roh: The Wolf Brigade

DVD released: September 3rd 2007.
Approximate running time:  98 minutes approx
Aspect ratio: 1.85:1 Anamorphic Widescreen
Rating: 15
Sound:
Dolby Digital 5.1/DTS
DVD Release: Optimum
Region Coding: PAL Region 2

Retail Price: £19.99


Reviewed by:
John White on August 21, 2007.

Quick links: [video] [audio] [extras] [overall]
The Film

Jin Roh was written by Mamoru Oshii, the director of Ghosts in the Shell, and directed by debutant Hiroyuki Okiura. Set in an alternative post world war 2 Japan where the military has taken over and an underground, the sect, has sprung up to fight it. The film opens with a young woman who is used as a bomb carrier cornered by the fearsome security force in a sewer. She makes to pull the string that will explode her bomb and despite himself the soldier cannot shoot. She explodes the device and he luckily survives but with a demotion. Unknown to him he is soon to become a pawn in a power game designed at ending the security force for good which will use a woman he believes to be the bomber's sister. Is he a sitting duck for this intrigue or is he less of a victim that he seems?

Where Ghosts in the Shell is as much about dazzling the eyes as the intellect, Jin Roh is a film with tremendous literary sensitivity and heart. The tale reveals itself piece by piece and the twist and turns on the way mean that little is as it seems. This clever unravelling is matched by a central romance between an insurgent bomber and the security force soldier which uses the device of the tale of Little Red Riding Hood to add pathos and emotional significance. This allows the thriller like convolutions to be intriguing but to ensure that the film has strong emotional punch. In the finale, it is hard to resist a tear as we learn that beasts must be beasts and humans must be humans.

It is a shame that the director has done precious little since this superb debut because Jin Roh is a great film. A film that asks whether any kind of leopard can change their spots and considers how the appearance of civility is actually gained through the unacknowledged strength of the violent and bestial. A film that almost 10 years on has added significance in a world of suicide bombers and the seduction of propaganda from both supposed "terrorists" and "liberators" alike. In the world of the film the real casualty of the tribalism and sectarianism is love and vulnerability.

An immense animation that is every bit the equal of the best of Oshii's work with an impact on the viewer which is more about feeling than technology.




Video 2.5/5

There is an existing R1 disc which has an adequate transfer but this is a poor standards conversion with combing and an edge of dullness to the overall look of the transfer. It is sharper than the R1 disc but there are incidents of sawtoothing, shimmering and combing that I noticed. Not so great really.



Audio 4/5
The audio is presented in 3 surround tracks including the fine DTS track which is also on the R1 disc and I think the subtitles may have been ported from there as well as they are the US yellow font that is so prevalent on R1 discs. The surround mixes give great depth and dynamism to the underground sequences and the English dub is actually very presentable for once even if the Japanese DTS track is the best on offer here.


Extras 3/5
The disc comes with production sketches, a theatrical trailer and interviews with Oshii and Okiura. Oshii laments not directing the film himself but recognises the emotional core that Okiura managed. The two men discuss the genesis of the film and Okiura's particular fussiness about the original story which he made Oshii rewrite. The extras are topped off with a trailer for Johnny To's Exiled and an Optimum Asia show reel of current releases.

 



Overall 3.5/5

A great film gets an ordinary video treatment, I am surprised at Optimum not converting the transfer properly as they don't usually skimp on such things. The extras may attract fans of the film who own the R1 for a double dip but the R1 disc is superior otherwise



Film Rating DVD Rating
Director: Hiroyuki Okiura
Films:

Writers: Mamoru Oshii
Video:

Released: 1998
Audio:

Cast:

(voices) Michael Dobson, Yoshikazu Fujiki, Sumi Mutoh, Moneca Stori

Extras:

Overall:

comment on this review in the forum


[Review Index] [Top of Page]
© copyright DVD Maniacs 2001-2007