Bone/God Told Me To/ Q: The Winged Serpent

DVD released: August 26, 2003
Approximate running time: 95, 92, 92 Minutes
Aspect ratio: Anamorphic 1.85.1
Rating: R
Sound: 6.1 DTS-ES, 5.1 Dolby Digital Surround EX, Dolby Surround 2.0, Original Mono
DVD Release: Blue Underground
Region Coding: Region 1 NTSC
Retail Price: $19.98 Each

Reviewed by:
Chris Poggiali on September 4, 2003



Quick links: [video] [audio] [extras] [overall]
The Film

There was talk some months ago when PHONE BOOTH was released to theatres about how much of that film’s success could be credited to the original screenplay by veteran filmmaker Larry Cohen. As someone who didn’t find the movie in the slightest bit suspenseful or interesting, and who has no qualms heaping the blame for that squarely on the shoulders of director Joel Schumacher and The Committee to Rewrite Larry Cohen, I now divert your attention to 3 new DVDs from Blue Underground that capture the brilliance and spontaneity of this underrated maverick writer-director: BONE, GOD TOLD ME TO, and Q, THE WINGED SERPENT, three of Cohen’s most effective and best-loved features. BONE, Cohen’s directorial debut, seems less of an anomaly when you consider his theater and live TV background before the film was made rather than the trajectory of his career afterwards. Basically a 3-act play with 4 principal characters, about an angry Black man (Yaphet Kotto) who forces his way into the ritzy home of a bickering white middle-aged Beverly Hills couple (Andrew Duggan and Joyce Van Patten), BONE should’ve gone to all the parties TWO-LANE BLACKTOP and THE HIRED HAND were invited to -- should’ve had the chance to hobnob with DUSTY AND SWEETS MCGEE and CISCO PIKE -- could’ve played inner city double bills with SWEET SWEETBACK’S BAADASSSSS SONG -- and at least gotten a mention in “Easy Riders, Raging Bulls.” Only in the early ‘70s could a film like this get made, get released and re-released under 2 or 3 different titles and erroneously plugged as everything from sexploitation to blaxploitation, and still get buried in the end. Well acted, sharply written and directed. Fresh, yet still clearly a product of its time -- the opening, set in a junkyard littered with almost as many corpses as cars, seems like a National Lampoon piece from the early days of Beard, Kenney and O’Donoghue, while the frantic widow who tells of her husband’s x-ray death at the hands of every dentist in California could be a Robert Klane outtake, like the drooling, half-human football player who tears off an opponent’s head and runs it in for a touchdown (a “Where’s Poppa?” courtroom testimony that never made it to the screenplay). Add a dash of “The Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” for a denouement and you’ll think maybe Cohen had the right idea trying to shoot this in 16mm black-and-white.

Cohen’s most ambitious and compelling work, GOD TOLD ME TO starts with a bang, literally, and never lets up. Original leading man Robert Forster was miscast -- I can’t picture him chewing gum in church, no sirree bob -- and thankfully replaced by the more ethnic Tony Lo Bianco, who turns in an A+ performance as Detective Lieutenant Peter Nicholas, NYPD. A churchgoing Catholic married to one woman (Sandy Dennis) but living in sin with another (Deborah Raffin), Nicholas begins to question his beliefs and his very existence while investigating a bizarre rash of killings perpetrated by normal citizens who claim “God told me to” when questioned about their motives. You can draw a line from GOD TOLD ME TO directly to one M. Night Shyamalan movie (UNBREAKABLE), possibly a second (SIGNS), and – stylistically speaking – everything dramatic that’s on TV right now from NYPD BLUE to 24. And give Cohen extra credit for not only cooking up a juicy cameo for Richard Lynch’s fire-scarred midsection, but also for giving a break to an almost bigger risk-taking trickster than himself -- Andy Kaufman, seen here wearing a police uniform and a mile-wide smile just before the guns start blazing. A friend of mine who caught this irresistible low-budgeter at the drive-ins of rural Pennsylvania several times during the ‘70s, both under its original title as well as the sobriquet DEMON, swears it was met with open hostility from the audience more than once. “The good, God-fearing country folk didn’t know what the heck they were seeing,” he told me, “but they knew they didn’t like it.”

Q is Cohen’s valentine to the “giant monster in the big city” sub-genre, but it owes as much to Damon Runyon and Ed McBain as it does to Harryhausen and Danforth. Shifty-eyed con Jimmy Quinn, portrayed by an Oscar-worthy Michael Moriarty, is small-time when compared to the crooks he does jewelry store stick-ups with, and positively miniscule next to the “plumed serpent” he discovers nesting at the top of the Chrysler Building. Quinn has his own egg to hatch -- a plan to withhold the whereabouts of the nest in order to blackmail the City of New York for a big payday. Meanwhile, the screeching winged serpent (an ancient Aztec god brought back to life by cultists who flay their victims during human sacrifices, you see) continues to decapitate construction workers, window washers, and topless sunbathers all over the Big Apple. Kwai Chang Caine and John Shaft are the detectives trying to piece it all together. Carradine, in fact, turns in one of the strongest performances of his career, especially when he’s riffing with Moriarty and unafraid to let the other steal the scenes -- music, in other words, but not the scat Quinn tortures the barflies with earlier in the movie. More like a Motown duet, with Carradine handling the smooth side like Marvin Gaye and laying the groundwork just before that Tammi Terrell buzzsaw starts up and drowns out everything else. Now, picture Bruce Willis in the Carradine role, Eddie Murphy in the Moriarty role, and the year is still 1982. [Pause] Right. Neither can I.





 





Video Bone 5/5; God Told Me To 4/5; Q 3/5
Regarding BONE,  one of the earliest videocassettes of Cohen’s freshman effort – released by New World Video in cut version as HOUSEWIFE – served its purpose in 1985, but the tape issued by Kino a few years ago (as BONE) was a flat-out visual abomination. For the DVD debut, Blue Underground has done a superb job restoring the film from its original negative materials. Simply put, this is the type of presentation that drove us all to purchase DVD players in the first place. GOD TOLD ME TO has been fully restored from the original negative. I don’t have the laserdisc or previous DVD versions for comparison purposes, but I’m also not the type to make a federal case out of dirt speckles or emulsion scratches. It looks a hundred times better than the old Charter tape and it’s letterboxed -- let’s leave it at that. Q is from the negative, but something went wrong. The film doesn’t look nearly as good here as it did on the old Anchor Bay DVD. Colors aren’t as strong. Faces disappear in the shadows. You may want to hold on to your old AB disc.



Audio 4/5
Since BONE is a low-budget, dialogue driven movie from over 30 years ago, I was expecting an audio track that would force me to crank up the volume past 18 in order to hear every word. Thankfully, this isn’t the case. The Mono track is crisp and clear. In addition to the original mono track and Dolby Surround soundtracks both, GOD TOLD ME TO and Q are given new DTS and 5.1 Dolby Digital Surround EX mixes. These new mixes sound decent given that they were originally mono films. Dialogue is clear -- no complaints. I can hear the characters say “God told me to” without cranking up the volume past 15, so that’s good enough for me.


Extras 4/5

BONE: The star of the show here is the terrific feature-length audio commentary with Larry Cohen and frequent collaborator William Lustig.  All the production bases are covered here, from the script process to the post-production and marketing of the movie.  “Jack H. Harris on BONE” is a 7-minute clip in which producer Harris tells the history of BONE from his point of view.  Thirty minutes of footage from the aborted first shoot of the movie are also included.  Originally to be filmed in 16mm black-and-white, with Pippa Scott in the Joyce Van Patten role, these crudely shot scenes speak volumes about Cohen’s ability to work well under pressure and his knack for skirting disaster.  Theatrical trailers, a radio spot, a poster & still gallery, and a Larry Cohen bio round out the package.

Easter Egg Alert: If you go to the Extras page, move down to “Jack H. Harris on BONE,” and then veer right, you’ll highlight a little television set.  Click on that and you’ll be rewarded with an episode of the half-hour 1960s CBS sitcom “You’re Only Young Twice,” featuring Ed Wynn, Ethel Waters, Kathryn Hays, BONE star Andrew Duggan and a young Larry Cohen goofing it up!

GOD TOLD ME TO: Cohen and Lustig provide another fascinating feature-length audio commentary.  If you haven’t heard Cohen’s commentaries yet, you really owe it to yourself to seek them out.  Like the ones recorded by Peter Bogdanovich, they can best be described as entertaining 90-minute film school classes for couch potatoes.  Also included: the theatrical trailer and 7 different radio spots (narrated by Ernie “Ghoulardi” Anderson), a poster & still gallery, and a Larry Cohen bio.

Easter Egg Alert: Go to the Audio menu and maneuver upwards to reveal “GOD.”  Click on that and you will be treated to 8 minutes of video footage (shot by our own Edwin Samuelson!) of a Q&A session with Cohen and New York Press critic Armond White that preceded a screening of GOD TOLD ME TO last October at the Walter Reade Theater at Lincoln Center.

ES: I'm sorry about the poor camera work; I just got the camera the previous day and didn't know how to use it properly. :)

Q,  THE WINGED SERPENT: The feature-length audio commentary by Cohen and Lustig is reason enough to pick up this disc, although folks equipped with more souped-up computers than the one I’m presently typing on tell me that the “Q Memorabilia” DVD-ROM features are also quite impressive.  A teaser trailer, poster & still gallery, and Cohen bio are also thrown in for good measure.



Overall 4/5
BONE is a treat for those familiar with the film, and an eye-opener for those who aren’t, Blue Underground’s beautiful presentation is currently on my list of the Top 10 DVDs of the Year. No complaints whatsoever.

GOD TOLD ME TO, another great Larry Cohen movie, has been given the kick-ass treatment we’ve come to expect from Blue Underground.

Q isn't as essential as the BONE or GOD TOLD ME TO discs, thanks to the questionable transfer, but this is still a pretty great disc and a must-buy for the DVD-ROM extras and the audio commentary.


Film Rating DVD Rating
Director: Larry Cohen
Films:

Writers: Larry Cohen
Video:

Released: 1970/1977/1982
Audio:

Cast: Andrew Duggan, Joyce Van Patten, Yaphet Kotto,/ Tony Lo Bianco, Sandy Dennis, Mike Kellin, Richard Lynch, Deborah Raffin, Andy Kaufman/David Carradine, Michael Moriarty, Candy Clark, Richard Roundtree
Extras:

Overall:

comment on this review in the forum


[Review Index] [Top of Page]
© copyright DVD Maniacs 2001-2002